An original brick cottage beside a taller cream brick home, framed by mature autumn trees and tidy front gardens on an established Atlanta street.

What Morningside's 2026 Prices Tell a Buyer

The house at 705 E. Morningside Drive went up in 1928 as the Atlanta Constitution Model Home, five years after Morningside opened in 1923. Close to a century later, that house and the six 1926 Mediterranean stucco houses on Sherwood Avenue sit on the same Morningside map as an 8,900-square-foot home on Reeder Circle that was finished in 2025 and sold this fall for $4.35 million.

A buyer looking at Morningside this week will see list prices from under $800,000 to over $5 million. That spread reads like a split between old and new. Divide each price by the square footage, though, and most of the gap disappears. Morningside buyers pay roughly the same per foot for a 1920s bungalow as for a house built last year. The price difference between the two comes mostly from how much house stands on the lot.

The same street grid, priced by the foot

Here are recent Morningside sales and asking prices across the neighborhood's main types of house. Asking prices are as of mid-November 2026. Closed sales show their dates.

Address Built Size Price Per sq. ft. Status
Yorkshire Road 1935 1,906 sq. ft. $799,000 about $419 Asking, mid-November 2026
University Drive 1925 1,665 sq. ft. $895,000 about $538 Asking, mid-November 2026
839 Wildwood Road 1940 1,882 sq. ft. $1,195,000 about $635 Asking, mid-November 2026
1258 N. Morningside Drive 1928, expanded 2003 2,365 sq. ft. $1,200,000 about $507 Sold May 4, 2026
Lenox Road 1955 5,631 sq. ft. $1,895,000 about $337 Asking, mid-November 2026
991 Courtenay Drive 2026 5,441 sq. ft. $2,995,000 about $550 Asking, mid-November 2026
1033 Reeder Circle 2025 8,900 sq. ft. $4,350,000 about $489 Sold Oct. 30, 2026

The two newest houses in the table come out at about $489 and $550 a square foot. Both figures fall inside the range of the original homes listed beside them. For the 12 months ending November 13, 2026, the median sold price per square foot across Morningside's closed sales was $478. The Reeder Circle sale, the largest home here, closed within about $11 a foot of that median.

The 1955 house on Lenox Road comes in lowest per foot. It is a big mid-century house in a neighborhood where most of the original stock is 1920s and 1930s. On a per-foot basis, the market has priced it as space more than as period character.

Asking prices are not closing prices, and these homes differ in condition, lot and finish. Still, the pattern is consistent enough to change the question. A Morningside buyer is mostly deciding how many square feet they want on one of these streets. Original versus new matters less than it first appears.

The lots were drawn in the 1920s and 1930s

Morningside's footprint was set in pieces, over about a decade. That is why the land under a modest bungalow and the land under a new 8,900-square-foot house come from the same set of subdivisions.

The Morningside Lenox Park Association's history pages trace the order. The University Park subdivision of Tudor houses was developed around Lanier University in 1921. In the mid-1920s, Highland Park followed around Courtenay and Northview; Courtenay was first named Southview. Tudor building in Noble Park, Johnson Estates and Hylan Park started in 1930. Developer Daniel Noble Johnson lived at Homestead and Johnson, and he named Charline Avenue for his daughter. Hylan Park took in Zimmer, Reeder, and the block of Cumberland between Highland and E. Rock Springs. Herbert Kaiser planned Lenox Park in the early 1930s. The architecture firm Ivey and Crook designed its three model homes: The Barclay at 1607 Barclay Place, The Sussex at 1625 E. Sussex Road, and The Chateau at 963 Plymouth Road.

The association's timeline puts that history right beside this fall's sales. The $4.35 million new house on Reeder Circle stands in Hylan Park, a 1930 Tudor subdivision. The 2026 new build listed on Courtenay Drive is on a Highland Park street from the mid-1920s. The association's 2018 master plan describes the historic stock as one- and one-and-a-half-story Craftsman bungalows and Tudors. Those houses were built small for their lots. That leaves room for a later owner to build much more house without buying more land.

Builders are adding stories less and building new more

There are two ways to turn a 1,700-square-foot original into a 5,000-square-foot house, and Morningside has seen both.

The first is the addition. The N. Morningside Drive bungalow in the table was built in 1928 and got a second story and a full renovation in 2003. At 2,365 square feet, it sold this May for about $507 a foot, close to the per-foot price of the unexpanded originals listed now. Additions continue. The association's November 2025 newsletter reported a variance request for 1222 University Drive NE asking for smaller rear and side setbacks. Both the zoning committee and the association recommended approval.

The second is a new house. In a January profile, Rough Draft Atlanta reported that Kris White started Broad Builders 15 years ago doing large renovations of 1920s bungalows in Virginia-Highland, Morningside and nearby neighborhoods, and has since moved about half of the business to building new homes. White described the earlier work to the paper as "adding a second story, additional square footage, creating outdoor spaces, detached garages; working with older homes in the area and trying to preserve the look." She also told Rough Draft that the difficulty with older homes is matching original hardware such as hinges, doors and doorknobs, and making the result "look like it's always been this way."

Both approaches lead to the same place. Since the market pays roughly the same per foot for old and new space, the choice between expanding and rebuilding comes down to cost, timing and how much of the original house a buyer wants to keep. It doesn't come down to which approach Morningside will reward more at resale.

Where the per-foot pattern runs out

Morningside's 2026 price ceiling was set by a one-owner custom house that sits outside the table above.

In October, Rough Draft Atlanta reported that 1770 Merton Road closed for $4.75 million, the highest recorded sale in Morningside's history. The house had one owner. Frank Neely designed it and Neil Johnson of Canonbury Homes custom-built it, with a limestone, granite and slate exterior, a pool and a putting green. Without a published square footage, the sale stays off the per-foot scale. Its price came from a custom stone house that had one owner.

A second house shows the same thing from the new-construction side. That house is 843 Yorkshire Road. Broad Builders brought it to market in late January at $5.49 million, according to Rough Draft. It is a California-inspired house of stone, wood and glass with seven bedrooms and seven and a half baths. The property's own page lists 7,089 square feet in the main house plus a 1,025-square-foot pool house. On the main house alone, the January asking price works out to about $774 a square foot, well above every figure in the table. Broad Builders' project page currently describes the home as available for purchase.

Above the roughly $420 to $640 band in the table, Morningside's top-end pricing rests on individual houses: their materials, their design and who built them.

Supply gives buyers room to compare

Current conditions give buyers time to weigh these trade-offs. In the 12 months ending November 13, 2026, Morningside recorded 19 closed sales at a $1.65 million median price, with a median of 24 days on market and 7.6 months of supply. Thirteen homes were active or pending as of that date. With that much supply, the market leans toward buyers. A sample of 19 sales is small, too. One large new build closing can move the median price by a wide margin while the per-foot figure barely changes. That is why the per-foot figure is the steadier way to read this neighborhood.

The metro numbers give some context. The Atlanta REALTORS Association's September 2026 market brief reported an 11-county median sales price of $416,000 for September, up 1.5% from a year earlier, on 3,680 sales, down 18.5%. Prices are holding while fewer homes change hands. In Morningside, that gives an original-home buyer room to price a future addition before committing, and it gives a new-build buyer time to compare a finished house's per-foot price with the neighborhood's.

For sellers of original homes, the table points the same way. A 1925 or 1935 house is competing on price per foot with new construction a few streets away. Presentation, condition and the space a buyer can see themselves adding decide where it lands within that range. Our earlier guide to winning the bid on a Morningside character home covers the offer side. For the road changes on the neighborhood's western edge, see Morningside's two construction calendars.

Questions buyers raise about these numbers

Does a new build in Morningside cost more per square foot than an original home? Among the sales and asking prices from mid-November 2026 in the table, it generally does not. The 2025 home on Reeder Circle sold at about $489 a foot and the 2026 build on Courtenay Drive is asking about $550. Original homes ranged from about $419 to $635.

Why is the 1955 Lenox Road house so much lower per foot? At 5,631 square feet, it is a large mid-century house in a neighborhood built mainly in the 1920s and 1930s. Its asking price values it more as space than as period character.

What set Morningside's record price? The $4.75 million sale of 1770 Merton Road, a one-owner custom house designed by Frank Neely and built by Canonbury Homes, as Rough Draft Atlanta reported in October 2026.

If you own a Morningside original and want to know where it falls against both the bungalows and the new builds nearby, Shanna Smith would be glad to talk through how your house compares with this fall's sales. Request a private consultation or start with a home valuation.

Work With Shanna

Shanna's promise to provide each client with “Expert Guidance and Exceptional Service” is her personal commitment to delivering unique and personalized service to each individual client going through the buying and selling process, each step of the way.

Follow Me on Instagram